13
Smithson Investment Trust plc Annual Report for the year ended 31 December 2022
looking at the average growth of earnings per share, which excludes
working capital expenses, and which was +7% in the period. It is
perhaps worth mentioning that if recession starts to bite in 2023,
we may have to wait some time for these figures to improve
meaningfully. But we are confident that they will.
Regarding the final step, do nothing, it must be noted that as share
prices were volatile throughout the year, trading activity increased
significantly as we set out to take advantage of buying new positions
or increasing existing ones at lower valuations. This meant that
discretionary portfolio turnover, excluding any buybacks and the
investment of proceeds from new shares issued, was 42.8%
compared to just 9.5% in 2021. While this sounds like a high level,
it is worth noting that according to Morningstar, the average turnover
for actively managed equity funds tends to be above 60% and in
2020, the last year of such volatile markets, it was 86%.
Costs of dealing, including taxes, amounted to 0.03% (3 basis
points) of NAV in the period, slightly higher than the 0.02% incurred
in 2021. This may seem odd given there was much more
discretionary turnover this year, but the reason is that the overall
turnover of the fund, including the investment of the proceeds from
share issuance, which was very limited in 2022, was not that much
higher than last year. The Ongoing Charges Figure
1
was 0.9% of NAV
compared to 1.0% in 2021. This includes the Management Fee of
0.9%, applied to the market capitalisation of the Trust, which was
lower than the NAV for most of the year. Combined, this means the
Total Cost of Investment in the Trust was 0.93%.
1
Part of the turnover was generated by buying three companies
during the year after the decline in share prices resulted in attractive
valuations. Moncler, the Italian clothing company which designs and
produces high-end branded apparel, traces its roots back to 1952
and the invention of down-filled mountaineering coats, but fell on
hard times in the 1990s before being rejuvenated in the 2000s. It
now produces luxury items across several categories in clothing and
accessories. The company has until recently been expanding by
opening new Moncler branded stores, but this growth has been
boosted by acquiring the Stone Island brand in 2020. Stone Island
is another Italian luxury clothing company which has a similar profile
to Moncler’s in 2000, which is why management believe they can
greatly improve and grow the Stone Island brand, much as they have
done over the last 20 years with Moncler.
Since the inception of the fund, we have experienced success in
owning decentralised industrial conglomerates such as Halma and
Diploma. While the organic growth of these businesses is
acceptable, around the mid-single digit percent level, it is the
consistent, disciplined acquisition of high quality ‘bolt-on’ companies
that allow the groups to create substantial shareholder value over
time. In fact, we believe that in an era of higher interest rates and
lower asset prices, companies such as these, making frequent small
acquisitions – without significant additional debt - should stand to
benefit greatly. We acquired Addtech as it is another high quality
example of this type of company, with a very small head office
directing the allocation of the cash flow that is generated by its
independently managed businesses. Addtech, based in Sweden, has
140 subsidiaries and 3,000 employees grouped into five industrial
business areas including Industrial Process, Energy, Automation,
Components and Power Solutions. Itsorigins date back to 1906 and
it has had the same business concept for over 100 years. We can
therefore be confidentin its strategy over the next decade at least.
Finally, we bought a position in IDEX, an industrial company based
in the US. IDEX is another decentralised industrial conglomerate
which grows through small acquisitions, but this time in areas such
as pumps, meters and systems for high-value materials,
high-precision instrumentation for health and science industries, and
tools, valves and controls for the fire and rescue industry and other
applications, including clamping devices used on the Mars rover.
We also sold three companies in the period. The first was a US-based
boiler and heater manufacturer, AO Smith. While the company has a
very attractive US business operating in a tight oligopoly, its future
growth opportunities lie in areas with much more aggressive
competition, such as water heaters in China and water purification
in the US. For this reason, we became less optimistic on its ability to
sustain profitable growth and sold, fortunately before fears of
recession caused a significant decline in its share price.
The second company we sold was Wingstop. After the shares
troughed in the summer, the share price more than doubled into the
autumn, at which point they were trading at levels we no longer felt
comfortable with given the decline in cash flow the company was
experiencing post its pandemic boost. In addition, we were
concerned about the long-term CEO deciding to leave for ‘another
challenge’, a potential capital intensive investment into chicken
farming and an increasingly levered balance sheet.
Investment Manager’s Review
Strategic Report
1
These are APMs Definitions of these and other APMs used in the Annual Report, together with how these measures have been calculated, are disclosed on pages 78 to 79.