5
2024 Annual Report | Canadian General Investments, Limited
Trading activity in the sector was a little higher than normal this year,
as CGI’s largest holding in the Energy sector, Enerplus Corporation,
was subject to a takeover and disappeared mid-year. Enerplus had
been a very good performer for the portfolio, tripling in price since its
purchase in 2021 and providing over $20 million in realized gains. Some
of the proceeds were used to add to the Canadian Natural Resources
Limited holding. Canadian Natural is one of Canada’s senior oil and gas
companies and is a go-to, high quality investment for domestic and
foreign investors alike. The company has well defined and deliverable
financial targets and these are expected to bring meaningful increases
to shareholder returns in the near term. A new position was established
in Athabasca Oil Corporation, an intermediate producer of about
35,000 barrels per day. Athabasca has a very low decline base, huge
reserve life and a steady and predictable production profile. These
are attributes that fit well with CGI’s investment philosophy. Almost
entirely liquids (98%), it not only gives a pure play on global oil pricing
trends but should also benefit from a step-up function of pricing
received for its oil as a result of new pipeline take-away capabilities for
Albertan oil. A historic structural bottleneck, differentials received by
producers for their oil based on the Western Canadian Select (WCS)
standard for pricing rather than the WTI standard quoted in the U.S.
are likely to narrow and add value to their barrels.
A nuclear industry renaissance may be in the offing. Nuclear energy
has come to be considered a viable solution for growing power needs
has become more acceptable and made a priority in social, corporate
and government circles. Several factors have aligned in its favour, not
the least of which are decarbonization initiatives, energy security
and new technologies. Investors are reminded that Canada has been
a global leader in the nuclear industry for a long time. It is uniquely
positioned with an endowment of rich uranium deposits and proven
capabilities and has companies that provide exposure in an otherwise
limited opportunity set. The timelines involved with the provisioning
of nuclear energy are naturally extended and encompass the full life
cycle of planning, construction and operations. That aligns well with
CGI’s focus on the longer term. A position in Cameco Corporation,
the world’s largest publicly traded uranium company, was initiated in
late 2023 and was increased in 2024. The company offers investors a
complete package of participation in most aspects of the nuclear fuel
cycle as well as operations management. The portfolio’s exposure to
the uranium play was further increased in 2024 with a new position
established in a company called NexGen Energy Ltd. NexGen is a
uranium development and exploration company focussed on the
Athabasca Basin in Saskatchewan, best known as the world’s leading
source of extraordinarily high-grade uranium and home to Cameco’s
major mines. NexGen’s flagship project is considered to be one of the
best undeveloped uranium deposits in the world and it is nearing the
end of a lengthy permitting process that, once approved, will enable
construction to begin. The mine, once complete, is expected to be the
largest and one of the lowest-cost uranium mines in the world.
Gold stocks had a breakout year and drove returns in the Materials
sector. Franco-Nevada Corporation, the premium gold royalty
company, is CGI’s lone holding in the group but it is of size and a top
ten holding. In the middle of the sector’s yearly performance rankings,
it reflects good participation in the rally but couldn’t match the
operating companies that tend to be more levered to the gold price.
This is to be expected as its stock tends to give very acceptable returns
in both good and bad years but doesn’t have the volatility of the
pure mining companies. A good fit for CGI, Franco-Nevada provides
a measured and rewarding means for gold exposure and, in the long
term, has handily outperformed the group since its purchase in 2007.
In Forest and Lumber, stocks remained sluggish as persistently high
interest rates did not allow for a much-anticipated rebound in the
weak U.S. housing market. Interfor Corporation, highly sensitive to
the pure lumber market, underperformed and lost over 20% in value.
It was eliminated. CGI’s remaining participant is West Fraser Timber
Co. Ltd. which has been a long-term, top ten holding and provides good
exposure to the group. It is considered as the go-to name for investors
and performed much better than Interfor, posting a reasonable double-
digit gain (11%) for the year. Lastly, in Materials, with good, but fragile
performance, was First Quantum Minerals Ltd. Its stock rebounded
about 70%, a big number, but was following on steep losses the year
before as speculation swirls about prospects for its Cobre Panama
mine which has been shut down by the government.
In other areas, steep losses in Communication Services were observed
as growth prospects diminished and competition ramped up in
the mature industry. Exposure to the group was reduced with the
elimination of Telus Corporation but the portfolio still suffered with its
lone remaining position, Rogers Communications, posting a 25% drop.
The Information Technology sector was the runaway leader in terms of
performance and many of CGI’s top individual performers come from
that area. It is also CGI’s largest overweight relative to the S&P/TSX,
an opportunity facilitated by the Company’s ability to invest in U.S.
securities, and the combination was a positive influence on relative
performance. Constellation Software Inc., Celestica Inc., Shopify
Inc., Apple Inc. and The Descartes Systems Group Inc. all generated
extremely good returns in excess of 35% but NVIDIA Corporation,
CGI’s largest holding, was the standout and soared over 170%. Not a
recent addition, it was originally bought in 2016 and has exhibited very
strong growth ever since. Tracking its rise in the markets and following
on the Manager’s traditional investment discipline to take profits
prudently, sales in the investment have been made every year since
purchase except for 2019. This year alone, gains approximating $100
million were realized and lifetime gains now approach $200 million. It
has been a terrific investment for the Company.
Dividend and interest income was $20,754,000 for the year, down
2.8% from 2023. Management fees and interest and financing
charges are the largest expenses of the Company. Management fees
increased by 17.4% to $17,079,000 due to higher average portfolio
values during the period. Interest and financing charges increased
15.6%, as a result of a higher amount of average borrowings during
2024 compared to 2023, due both to the use of margin borrowings to
fund the redemption of the Company’s $75 million Class A preference
shares, Series 4 on June 12, 2023, as well as a $25 million increase in
aggregate borrowings during the fourth quarter of 2024.
Leverage
The Company has a prime brokerage services agreement with a Canadian
chartered bank. Amounts borrowed under this agreement bear interest
at the Canadian Overnight Repo Rate Average (CORRA) plus 0.42% per
annum (CORRA plus 0.90% prior to June 1, 2024 and the one-month
Canadian Dollar Offered Rate (CDOR) plus 0.60% prior to May 1, 2024).
The agreement requires the Company to pledge securities as collateral
for margin borrowings and may be terminated immediately by the prime
broker upon the occurrence and continuation of an event of default, as
defined in the agreement, or by either party with 30 days’ notice.