
‘Windfall gains’
The Committee carefully considered
whether a downward adjustment
should be made to the PSP vesting
outcome in 2023 to take account of
the COVID pandemic-related stock
market ‘shock’ around the time of
grant in March 2020 – specifically
the impact of this on the number of
shares that were awarded. Due to
the general stock market fall, the SJP
share price at the time of grant was
£7.13, compared to £10.26 at the time
of the prior year’s grant in 2019. This
resulted in Executive Directors being
granted 44% more shares at the 2020
grant than they had received at the
prior year’s grant (excluding the
impact of year-on-year salary
changes on the grant value).
The Committee considered a number
of balancing factors in assessing
whether an adjustment should be
made at vesting for this ‘windfall gain’:
The fall in the share price around the
time of grant was not a consequence
of SJP’s performance or that of the
management team. It was a global
phenomenon resulting from the
COVID pandemic ‘shock’.
Our Executive Directors were not
insulated from the negative effects
on vesting values of the COVID-
related market ‘shock’. These
negative effects included the
impact on the value of 2017 PSP
awards vesting in 2020, and the
value of deferred bonuses earned
for the 2016 performance year that
vested in the spring of 2020.
Our Executive Directors were also
not insulated from the economic
effects of the pandemic on
performance outcomes for 2018
PSP awards vesting in the spring of
2021 (which vested at only 9% of
maximum, compared with 63% for
the 2017 PSP awards vesting for
performance to the end of 2019
before the pandemic).
Unlike many FTSE 350 companies,
we awarded zero bonus for 2020,
despite robust performance
relative to the non-financial criteria
that made up 50% of the annual
bonus. Executive Directors also
received zero base salary increases
in spring 2021 and voluntarily
waived 20% of base salary for three
months during 2020. The Chief
Executive’s and the Chief Financial
Officer’s total remuneration for
2020 was, respectively, 43% and
33% lower than for the prior year, in
the context of the COVID pandemic.
SJP did not draw upon government
support during the COVID
pandemic, nor make any COVID-
related redundancies, and we
reinstated the proportion of the
withheld 2019 final dividend in
March 2021.
If there had, instead, been a share
price ‘spike’ at the time of the
award, the Committee would not
have increased the size of award
in order to align it with the size of
the previous year’s award. The
Committee has not compensated
Executive Directors for any share
price ‘spike’ at the time of award in
previous year’s. For example, the
award price of the PSP in March
2014 spiked at a level 65% higher
than the previous years’ award,
resulting in 40% fewer shares being
awarded; however, no upward
adjustment was made to the
award size to mitigate this negative
impact on Executive Directors.
Having considered all the relevant
factors, the Committee concluded
that no adjustment will be made to
the PSP vesting outcome in respect of
the 2020 PSP awards due to vest in
March 2023 for the Executive Directors.
Changes to the Board
Ian Gascoigne retired as Managing
Director from the Board and the
Company on 31 March 2022. His
remuneration in this Report is for
the portion of the year that he served
until the date he left the Board. He
remained eligible for annual bonus
for the part of 2022 that he served
as a Executive Director. Full details
of the treatment of Mr Gascoigne’s
remuneration on retirement were
set out in last year’s Report.
On 1 November 2022 we welcomed
Dominic Burke as a Non-executive
Director onto the Board. Details of the
remuneration for all of the Directors
serving throughout the year
can be found later in the Report.
As announced during October 2022,
I will be retiring from the SJP Board
at the conclusion of the 2023 AGM
having served as a Director for nine
years. In accordance with succession
plans, it is the SJP Board’s intention,
subject to regulatory approval,
to appoint Emma Griffin as my
successor. I would like to take this
opportunity to thank the Committee
members, management and
shareholders for their support during
my time as Chair of the Committee.
Proposed Policy for 2023-25
The Committee has undertaken
a thorough review of the Policy in
preparation for the triennial AGM
vote, including consulting with major
shareholders as set out above, and
taking account of remuneration for
other SJP employees. The Committee
concluded that the overall
remuneration structure continues to
be suitable for SJP and is aligned to our
strategic goals. Where amendments
have been proposed to the Policy
and practice, these are intended
to: support the continued growth of
the business over the next three years;
assist retention and, when necessary,
recruitment of talent; and, ensure that
the Policy includes features of best
practice in UK executive remuneration.
The key proposed changes to the
Policy and practice are:
to increase the weighting on
financial metrics in the annual
bonus to 60% (from 50% currently),
with a corresponding reduction
in the strategic and operational
metrics weighting to 40% (from
50% currently);
to align the maximum annual
bonus more closely with market
norms for companies of SJP’s size.
The current maximum of 150% of
base salary (with half deferred into
shares) compares with medians of
230-275% of base salary for CEOs
and CFOs in listed financial sector
companies of our size. We propose
to increase the bonus maximum
in two stages, to 175% in 2023, and
to 200% for 2024 and beyond –
still below the median levels in
other financial sector companies.
Maximum award levels for the
PSP are unchanged at 250% of
base salary;
to reduce the weight of the
Embedded Value (EV)-based
Earnings Per Share (EPS)
performance metric in the PSP to
one third (from two thirds currently)
and introduce a Cash Result-based
EPS performance metric with a
weighting of one third. Relative
Total Shareholder Return (TSR)
will continue to be used as a
performance metric for the
remaining third. These
performance metrics provide
a good balance, reflecting
performance over the long-term
in growing the business and in
delivering value and cash flows
for shareholders;
145
Strategic Report Financial Statements Other Information
www.sjp.co.uk
Governance