
45
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR’S REPORT TO THE MEMBERS OF AVATION PLC (CONTINUED)
Risk
Our response to the risk
Key
observations
communicated
to
the
Audit
Committee
Valuation of Aircraft (2023: US$845.5
million,2022:US$813.9 million)
Refer to Note 3 (g) of the Accounting
policies (page 66); Note 6 (page 87) and
Note 18 of the Consolidated Financial
Statements (page 104).
The carrying value of jet and turboprop
aircraft represent the most significant
asset in the financial statements of
Avation plc. As at 30 June 2023, the
carrying value of aircraft reported is
US$845.5
million
(2022:
US$813.9
million) as detailed in Note 18 of the
financial statements.
As set out within on pages 64-66 Notes
3 (f) and 3 (g) ‘Summary of Significant
Accounting
Policies’,
aircraft
are
measured at fair value on a Lease
Encumbered Value basis (“LEV”). As
detailed in Note 4 (b) ‘Critical Accounting
Estimates
and
Judgments’,
management applies estimation and
judgment as part of their fair value
assessment of aircraft.
For the purposes of determining the
valuation, the carrying value of each jet
and turboprop is compared to the
computed LEV. LEV is determined by
discounting the lease income streams
associated with the lease and the
expected future residual value of the
aircraft at the end of the lease adjusted
for return conditions at lease termination
using an appropriate discount rate.
The nature and size of these balances
and their importance to the Group are
such that we have identified this as a key
audit matter.
We have assessed each aircraft as they are
deemed to be individually material to the
financial statements. In obtaining sufficient
audit evidence we:
•
Obtained
an
understanding
of
the
process for the valuation of aircraft on an
LEV basis and performed a walkthrough
of the process, including controls over
the
inputs
and
assumptions
of
calculation, and evaluated the design of
controls in relation to the identified risk.
•
Assessed
and
evaluated
the
appropriateness and accuracy of the key
assumptions
used
in
the
LEV
calculation, through recalculation and
scenario analysis.
•
Involved specialists from our valuations
and business modelling team to assess
the reasonableness of the discount rates
used in discounting the future cash flows
of aircraft in the model. As part of our
audit procedures, we also evaluated the
appropriateness of credit premia and
discounts applied by management for
each
lessee
by
analysing
their
respective credit risks.
•
Evaluated
the
independence
and
competence of experts engaged by
management in valuing the LEV in
accordance with the requirements of
auditing standards.
•
Assessed the accuracy of factual inputs,
such as lease income streams, by
reviewing
lease
agreements
and
amendments, as necessary.
•
Assessed the calculations underpinning
the LEV model by checking that the data,
the assumptions and inputs into the
model were in agreement with those that
we had evaluated in other areas of the
audit.
•
Assessed
the
appropriateness
and
presentation
of
disclosures
in
the
financial statements for compliance with
the relevant accounting standards.
Our
planned
audit
procedures
were
completed
without
material exception.